Menu Close

Confession #140: I Want More Asian Style Storytelling

As a U.S. citizen, I feel compelled to acknowledge that this past week has been a helluva ride. Both the political landscape and the unchecked spread of COVID in my state (as many others) and across the country have contributed to perhaps the most stressful period of my life.

My primary method of coping has been watching streaming video. There has been the occasional dip into Doctor Who, with my regular reviews or catching up on the last series with the Ladies of WhoFest, but for the most part, I’ve been streaming dramas from Korea, China, or (occasionally) Japan. Not only do these stories distract me from the dumpster fire of the world around me, but they stimulate my mind in new ways.

One thing that has fascinated me so much about them is that these stories from Asian cultures have very different storytelling conventions than the ones I’m used to. As a fiction writer myself, I’ve learned that the art of making a story satisfying to the reader (or viewer) hinges on delivering on implicit promises. Those promises vary from genre to genre.

For example, in romance, it is expected that every story will have an HEA—Happily Ever After—and if it doesn’t, it’s not romance. If you present a story as romance but fail to resolve the protagonists’ storyline with them getting together and building a sweet life together, your audience will riot because it goes against the accepted genre norms. Even in other genres, we’ve come to expect that Good will triumph over Evil and even if not everything is peachy at the end, things are headed in a more positive direction than at the beginning of the story.

At least, that’s how it works in Western storytelling.

Confession #139: I’ve Lost All Concept of Time

It’s weird how malleable our perception of time is. People have long observed that as we age, time seems to pass more quickly, and that how engrossed we are in whatever we’re doing affects how we experience the passage of time (see: “time flies when you’re having fun” or “I was playing a game and lost track of the time”).

The pandemic has been particularly hard on our mushy human sense of time. It simultaneously seems like these last seven (yes, seven!) months since my community first started sheltering in place have flown past and dragged on forever. We remember how the world worked before COVID with nostalgia, but forget how very recent that time was.

A particular example really struck me a week or so ago. (There’s another instance of losing track of relative time. This particular thought might’ve come up last week or last month, for all I can remember. I frequently find myself thinking back to somwhat-recent-but-long-passed events, and then realize they happened that morning.) I got to thinking about how everything had changed for film and television production, and that we’d end up waiting just ages between series of Doctor Who.

Then it struck me that Series 12 was this year. That happened in 2020. I watched an episode with my friends a Gallifrey One* just this past February.

Confession #138: I Hope Gallifrey One Goes Virtual

A few days ago I had the pleasure of chatting with some of my Gally friends over video chat, which—let’s be honest—is a higher frequency of synchronous face-to-face (if not in-person) interaction than we get in a usual year. Due to the fact that we all know each other exclusively thanks to that con, and the continuing uncertainty and weirdness of the times, we naturally got to wondering about how Gallifrey One would likely proceed for its upcoming convention, scheduled for February 2021.

Frankly all of us believe an in-person con will not be happening next year (in fact, the topic came up in conversation in the form of “what are the bets for when they’ll be cancelling?”). Given how irresponsible Americans in general are being about containing COVID (see, for example, a recent study about the impact of the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally having gone forward this year), I can’t even conceive of a way it will be safe to gather three-to-four thousand people in a hotel convention center within the next five months.

So what might the concom do instead? It’s a tough call. A great many conventions have pivoted to making their cons a virtual experience. Given how new the 100%-online concept is for conventions, and how much in-person cons vary anyway, it is unsurprising that such events have met with various degrees of success. (For example, I heard vastly different reactions within the SFF writing community as to how the Nebula Conference and WorldCon were executed.)

Confession #137: I’m Beyond Excited for New Big Finish

A couple of days ago, news crossed my various social media timelines that I had begun to despair of ever seeing for real: Christopher Eccleston has signed on with Big Finish to bring us more Ninth Doctor adventures! Given Eccleston’s well known reluctance to talk much about his time on the show, and outright resistance to the idea of returning, this news feels kissed with a touch of the miraculous.

According to the news item published on the Big Finish website, talks began between Big Finish executives and Eccleston at this year’s Gallifrey One convention. Since the former Doctor even got unexpected pressure (such as it was) from Radio Free Skaro‘s Steven Schapansky, I think it’s safe to say he got the idea that it’s something fans might actually want.

I can understand why he might not want to reprise the role. Although I believe him when he says he loved playing the Doctor, a bad work environment is going to leave a bad taste in anyone’s mouth. Having the corporate entity in charge of the franchise release a statement on one’s behalf—without consultation or agreement—that results in abuse from supposed fans leveled at one’s ailing, aged parent? That’s gonna be even harder to forgive.

But I think he’s finally had the opportunity to learn how very dearly Ninth Doctor fans hold him in our hearts. After so many bad experiences with those just looking to turn a quick buck, his entry into the convention circuit has put him face-to-face with those of us who adore his Doctor, and by proxy adore him for his performance.

I get the sense that we con attendees got to be the Whos of Whoville (how apropos) to Eccleston’s Grinch, showing him the true meaning of our abiding love for this show. That’s what I’m telling myself, anyway. I’d like to think that I am, in some small way, partly responsible for helping bring about this new collection of audio adventures.

So what can we expect? There will be four volumes in the new Ninth Doctor Adventures series, released May, August, and November 2021, and February 2022. Each volume is listed as four discs with a total length of 240 minutes. That likely means four hour-long adventures in each volume, but could mean three adventures and a special features disc.

As for supporting cast, that’s all still under wraps (or, more likely, not yet contracted). I’d be very surprised, though, if we don’t get Billie Piper back as Rose Tyler. During the Gallifrey One 2020 interview panel I alluded to above (in which Schapansky was the interviewer), Eccleston fielded a question about who his potential Companion(s) might be should he ever choose to return to the role in, say, audio format. He responded with, “Well, it could only ever be Rose.”

Given Eccleston’s own inclinations, then, and the fact that Piper has already reprised her role with Big Finish both alongside David Tennant (for three stories in The Tenth Doctor Adventures, Volume 2) and alongside Camille Coduri (Jackie Tyler) and Shawn Dingwall (Pete Tyler), I think there’s a high probability that they’ll get her for at least one of the four volumes of The Ninth Doctor Adventures. But we’ll have to wait to see for sure.

However it pans out, I believe it will be Fantastic.

Confession #136: I Want the Doctor’s Reassurance

We’re many months into the COVID-19 pandemic, and my country in particular is failing wildly in containing its spread. Humans are bad at things like statistics and understanding risk, and Americans—who have been acculturated to value “rugged individualism” (ugh)—are additionally bad at doing things for the greater good at the cost of individual convenience. So it both feels like it’s already been going on forever and appears like it will continue… forever.

At moments like these I really wish the Doctor would pop in to visit me and give me some encouraging words. I mean, according to the adventures we’ve been privy to, humanity makes it long-term. We expand out among the stars (like a virus… wait—bad analogy), having clearly made it through some terrible stuff on our home planet. Surely we’ll make it through this, too.

But the details just might do me in. I mean sure, humanity might survive, but at what cost? And that doesn’t mean that any particular state or institution (looking at you, US of A) will survive this Moment. While it may be true that “Darkness never sustains,” it can still last a helluva long time. What will we all have to survive to get through this?

Confession #135: I Cannot Remain Silent

Let me begin by making my stance crystal clear: Black Lives Matter.

Readers may or may not already know that I live in the Twin Cities—the Minneapolis/St Paul metro area in Minnesota. My cities have been in the news a lot these last couple of weeks after a white, then-member of the Minneapolis Police Department knelt on the neck of a Black man named George Floyd, resulting in Floyd’s death. Since then protests and riots have erupted across the world.

This certainly feels like one of those historic Moments—something the Doctor might pop in to visit, to witness in person. I almost thought I’d gotten used to that feeling, to recognizing in realtime the unfolding of events that future generations (should humanity survive) will see as significant. The year 2020 has kept us all on our toes, though, and every time I’m still caught by surprise. “Wow,” I think to myself as something new crops up. “This is huge.”

The thing is, of course, that none of us can know just how huge any moment—any movement—will become. So what I try to remember is that if it’s something I believe in, I have to take part. No matter how small or powerless I feel in the face of massive, far-reaching societal injustices, I have to do something.

Confession #134: I Can’t Think About the Show Right Now

As the world continues to struggle in the grip of COVID-19, and the US—the country with by far the highest incidence of the virus, and perhaps the poorest response—starts to decide just because it’s tired of this whole stay-at-home thing that surely it must be over now, I sit in front of my computer asking myself to think about Doctor Who. What’s wrong with this picture?

Actually, nothing. Because what the world really needs right now is a little bit of hope. Anything and everything we can find to give us a spark of joy, to keep us from buckling under the intense pressure of our collective trauma, to inspire us to do good for each other and ourselves is important. So if watching, thinking about, even arguing about Doctor Who with friends near and far can do that for any one of us, then so much the better.

Confession #133: I Lost Track of Time

Funny thing about being in self-isolation under a stay-at-home order from one’s state during a global pandemic: all the days kind of blend together.

That’s what I keep telling myself, anyway. Because otherwise I get really irritated with myself for having lost track of my blog schedule, and the fact that I should’ve posted last week. So here I am, checking in with anyone who still stops by the blog to read.

I was going to say that I have not been thinking about Doctor Who much at all, but as I began to write that, I realized that’s not quite true. The brand management team has been doing a good job keeping it on the radar across social media, and I’ve really appreciated that. Because sometimes we all just need a few encouraging words from the Doctor.

Here’s the first transmission, from 25 Mar 2020:

Confession #132: I Don’t Think Capaldi’s Series Are Bad

As part of a conversation with some friends online the other day, someone mentioned the upcoming series (only three more weeks to wait!) and that they needed to catch up on last series before the new one began. Then the conversation turned to Capaldi and his episodes.

Now regular readers will probably know that I adore Capaldi’s Doctor. So when folks wished for a list of the standalone Capaldi episodes worth watching, I was filled with excitement. Who better than me, I wondered, to provide such a list? But at the same time, it made me sad to think that so many people think his series aren’t worth watching. Sure, every Doctor has to slog through some stinkers, but I just don’t get why so many people think these episodes are that much worse than those of other Doctors.

The biggest issue, of course, is Moffat’s problematic showrunning. Some of Moffat’s ideas (like how his Companions kept being puzzles rather than people) really made my skin crawl. But by that same metric, Matt Smith’s Doctor shouldn’t be considered worth watching. I think the important thing to remember is that every era, every Doctor, has suffered from bad writing—some more so than others, I’ll admit—and that all judgements about quality are down to personal preferences.

That being said, I have compiled my own list of a few episodes from each of Capaldi’s three seasons that I think are worth a watch. I’ve included some notes on each one to give an idea of what it’s about and provide my own heads-up about the biggest pros and cons I remember. (If I’ve missed something major, please leave a comment so I can make the change. It has been a while since I’ve watched any of these…)

Confession #131: I Dislike Corporate Cons

This may be a vast overgeneralization (though, let’s face it, some of the biggest fan opinions are just vastly overgeneralized rants), but I have decided that I really don’t like those big, corporate cons. You know the ones: they bring in a slew of big-name celebrities from a ton of different fandoms and then charge people an arm and a leg for photo ops and autographs. After my first, and so far only, single afternoon of trying one out, I’ve made my mind up: they’re not for me.

I’m pretty sure this judgment makes me a hypocrite somehow. After all, I went to this one for the sole purpose of taking advantage of the ridiculous photo op machine that plays such a large role in making these cons unpalatable to me in the first place. Further, I participate in photo ops and autograph sessions at Gallifrey One all the time (though I’ve never had to wait an hour past the scheduled time slot just for the line to start moving at Gally). So what gives?

The big difference, to my mind, is that after a certain size, the con becomes too big for con-goers to feel like anything more than a number to the organization. At a super local, single fandom con like CONsole Room, it can feel like you know everybody there, at least by sight. Gally is nearly a factor of ten larger than CONsole Room, with an annual attendance just shy of 4000 (which includes staff and guests), yet it’s still every bit as much about hanging out with other fans—friends old or new—as about seeing the guests, whether at photo ops, autograph lines, or panels.