Solid Footing

Review of Thin Ice
Warning: This review contains episode-specific spoilers and wild speculation about future episodes.

While Bill thinks she may be "low-key in love with [the TARDIS]" (which I thought was both a beautifully subtle nod to Bill's sexual orientation and a lovely statement of sentiment), I'm definitely low-key in love with writer Sarah Dollard's work.

Dollard, who penned last series's Face the Raven, hit another one out of the park with Thin Ice, keeping Series Ten on solid footing. Bill is fast becoming my favorite post-Hiatus Companion, and the developments in her relationship with the Doctor under Dollard's guidance are my favorite yet.

Following the Series One formula of modern-day introduction followed by a future adventure and then a past one, the Doctor (or, more accurately, the TARDIS) takes Bill to Regency-era London. I knew I'd love this episode the instant I saw Bill's initial reaction to the time: reminding the Doctor that as a person with melanin-rich skin, she's likely to have a different experience out there than he is. Better yet, Twelve actually considers her words before acknowledging the (general) danger and sending her off to choose a frock (in stark contrast to Ten's complete dismissal of Martha's similar anxiety at the beginning of The Shakespeare Code).

Throughout the episode, the chemistry between these two continued to fill me with joy. (I'm so crushed at the thought that we'll have no more of Capaldi after this series, and likely no more of Mackie, either—which is nigh criminal, as she's so bloody brilliant.) The Doctor yanks Bill's chain at least twice about her interaction with time travel—the imaginary disappearance of "Pete" and seeing the lights under the ice—and proves himself both particularly admirable and particularly problematic in her eyes.

On the one hand, he seems refreshingly conscientious. When Bill notes that Regency England is "a bit more black than they show in the movies," the Doctor easily replies that "so was Jesus. History's a whitewash." (For those who might not know, in science fiction and fantasy writing circles, stories set in or based on historical Europe and populated solely with white characters are often defended with an argument of "historical accuracy." Despite that all-white vision of history being constantly debunked, the illusion persists. It's really nice to see it addressed right out in the open this way.)

Similarly, the Doctor throws a singularly satisfying punch (as Christopher Jones put it) on Bill's behalf when confronted with an overt racist. And he makes an impassioned speech about how "Human progress ... [is] measured by the value you place on ... an unimportant life." This attitude so impresses Bill that she comments on wanting to be able to speak that way herself at some point during her less-than-2000-year lifetime.

However, Bill also has to face the fact that her tutor/teacher/mentor has a dark side. The scene where she calls him to task for his apparent callousness over the death of the boy called Spider is a key moment in their relationship. And because she doesn't know him from before, she doesn't realize how far he has already come. On the ice after Spider is lost, he actually tells Kitty, "Sorry about your friend" before immediately trying to move on to saving Kitty and whatever other friends she might have. He didn't even need note cards.

But all Bill sees is the veneer. She doesn't see the pain, because he's gotten so good over the centuries at tucking it away and "moving on" in order to prevent further disasters that it doesn't show in his face or demeanor. She sees the Doctor refusing to express compassion and deflecting her questions, and she's having none of it. I love that she refuses to let him put her off with platitudes, that she pushes him until he gives straight answers to her uncomfortable questions. She knows she deserves the respect afforded by honesty, and demands it of him.

So while I understand the narrative necessity of resolving that character conflict within a matter of minutes, it still seems an awfully quick change of heart when Bill tells Kitty that she, too, has "moved on" from the argument. For the most part I buy it, since Bill has been made to recognize that there are other lives at stake now, but I'd have preferred the luxury of seeing that interpersonal dissonance resolve over a longer span.

Then there's the creature-of-the-week "Tiny" (aka the Loch-less Monster, aka the Not-So-Little Mermaid). When the TARDIS team finally come eye-to-eye with her (Yes, "her"! What other writer would've so casually thrown in the feminine pronoun for an unknown creature?), it's obvious she's a captive. I got flashes of The Beast Below, but more than anything, that moment put me in mind of the Torchwood episode Meat (fair warning: if you haven't seen that one and had a soft spot for Tiny, don't go search it out).

Tiny's a bit of a MacGuffin, but she also serves as the focus for another key interaction between the Doctor and Bill. Similarly to his behavior in Kill the Moon, the Doctor cedes responsibility for an important decision to Bill—except this time I don't nearly hate him for it. Somehow, I can almost buy his assertion that "[he serves] at the pleasure of the human race" (a much better explanation than in the prior case), but it doesn't jibe with his behavior in previous situations.

I'm left to wonder if this attitude has something to do with the Vault. While I'd really like that not to be the case, that's the most plausible explanation I've yet concocted for his sudden reluctance to act on humanity's behalf. In particular, he calls Bill "boss" in front of Nardole after they've returned to his office at university. Is that a way of telling Nardole he's keeping to the letter of his oath, if not the spirit? Time will tell.

For now, I'll bask in the afterglow of a truly top-notch episode.

Categories: 

Comments

I don't trust The Doctor when he says things like "I serve at the pleasure of the human race."

Like the situation with Clara in Kill the Moon, I think The Doctor was letting his companion make the decision as a kind of test. Put your money where your mouth is. You have judged me for my failure to sufficiently value human life when I'm not even human. How much do YOU value alien life forms and how far will you go to champion them?

I thought Clara's decision was profoundly stupid. But I thought Bill made the right one. The fish creature only ate humans because they were the only food offered and it was eat them or starve. Humans were obviously not her preferred food source. And since she had to be chained up there, the Thames was obviously not her preferred home. Left to her own devices, it was likely that she would swim off to one of the poles and eat whales (or whatever).

But Bill got the message. She realized that while The Doctor's hands weren't clean, the situation frequently demanded that people like the pirate keeping them prisoner in the tent had gotten exactly what was coming to them.

By Kara S (not verified)
mrfranklin's picture

I'm not sure I would agree that the Doctor was testing Bill, but the parallel with Kill the Moon is definitely the one that leapt out at me. I don't really trust his motives after a quote like that, either.

I *do* think Bill stepped up and did the right thing, and I have really enjoyed watching her character develop. I wish we could have three seasons of these two together!

By mrfranklin

coach factory outlet online
uggs outlet
mlb jerseys
burberry outlet
hermes bags
coach factory outlet online
red bottom
louboutin outlet
birkenstock outlet
uggs clearance
uggs on sale
cheap jerseys
ray ban sunglasses outlet
ugg boots
adidas outlet online
polo ralph lauren outlet
cheap uggs
pandora charms sale clearance
uggs
tory burch shoes
canada goose outlet
ugg boots
ugg canada
cheap jordan shoes
nike sneakers
coach outlet online
cheap ugg boots
coach outlet canada
canada goose
ugg boots sale
coach factory outlet online
coach factory outlet online
moncler coats
ralph lauren outlet online
ray ban sunglasses outlet
uggs outlet
tory burch outlet online
moncler uk
ralph lauren outlet
ugg outlet
coach outlet online
moncler jacket
pandora
ugg uk
michael kors outlet clearance
adidas yeezy boost 350
christian louboutin shoes
cheap oakley sunglasses
coach outlet store online
coach outlet online
michael kors
fitflop sandals
coach outlet online
louboutin shoes
polo ralph lauren outlet online
ralph lauren outlet online
pandora charms outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet
coach outlet online
ugg sale
longchamp bags
supreme london
bottes ugg
coach handbags outlet
pandora charms
louis vuitton outlet
kate spade outlet online
north face outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
north face jackets
coach outlet online
yeezy boost
cheap air jordans
birkenstock
nfl jerseys cheap
coach outlet online
canada goose jackets
mlb jerseys
air jordans
oakley sunglasses outlet
coach factory outlet online
ralph lauren uk
michael kors outlet online
cheap ray ban sunglasses
birkenstock uk
canada goose jackets
ralph lauren outlet
ralph lauren sale
adidas superstars
canada goose parka
polo ralph lauren outlet
oakley sunglasses outlet
louis vuitton outlet store
toms outlet
louis vuitton outlet online
toms
adidas superstar shoes
adidas nmd runner
fred perry polo shirts
ralph lauren uk
cheap uggs
uggs outlet
adidas ultra boost
pandora charms sale clearance
canada goose jackets
burberry uk
pandora charms
toms
michael kors
michael kors outlet online
michael kors outlet canada
polo ralph lauren outlet
canada goose clothing
canada goose outlet
pandora jewelry store
cheap jordan shoes
michael kors outlet online
coach factory outlet
cheap ugg sale
michael kors outlet clearance
uggs outlet
longchamp
harden vol 1
coach factory outlet online
michael kors outlet canada
ralph lauren outlet online
louis vuitton outlet online
nike air max 2018
michael kors outlet store
moncler outlet online
michael kors outlet store
kate spade handbags
birkenstock outlet store
nike outlet store
burberry outlet
pandora jewelry
coach factory outlet online
pandora outlet
christian louboutin sale
ralph lauren
mulberry outlet uk
coach outlet store
birkenstock shoes
uggs outlet
michael kors outlet online
coach outlet online
coach outlet online
burberry handbags
ralph lauren outlet
ralph lauren outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet
ugg outlet store
superdry outlet
coach outlet online
canada goose jackets
adidas outlet online
valentino
mbt
michael kors outlet clearance
cheap ugg boots
nfl jerseys wholesale
red bottom heels
caterpillar boots
louis vuitton outlet store
cheap jordans for sale
nike outlet store online
ugg boots women
ugg slippers
polo ralph lauren outlet online
nike shoes
ray ban glasses
uggs outlet
kate spade handbags
coach outlet online
moncler outlet online
toms outlet
ugg outlet
ugg boots outlet
cheap oakley sunglasses
pandora charms sale
superdry sale
jerseys cheap
christian louboutin shoes
air max
mulberry handbags
discount oakley sunglasses
coach outlet online
ray ban sunglasses cheap
canada goose outlet
christian louboutin shoes
uggs outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet online
canada goose jackets uk
pandora jewelry outlet
moncler jackets
coach factory outlet
fitflops sale clearance
kate spade outlet
ralph lauren sale clearance uk
coach outlet store
kate spade outlet online
moncler
coach outlet online
coach outlet canada
ralph lauren
canada goose coats
coach factory outlet online
nike cortez classic
mbt
louis vuitton factory outlet
adidas outlet store
michael kors uk
coach outlet store online
pandora charms
adidas yeezy boost
cheap nfl jerseys wholesale
canada goose jackets
louis vuitton factory outlet
ray ban sunglasses outlet
ugg boots
ugg boots
ugg boots
ugg boots outlet
kate spade handbags
coach outlet online
burberry outlet online
canada goose jackets
birkenstocks
moncler pas cher
ugg outlet online
louis vuitton outlet online
christian louboutin shoes
uggs outlet
mlb jerseys
supreme clothing
yeezy boost 350
yeezy shoes
oakley sunglasses outlet
michael kors outlet store
michael kors
coach outlet online
ugg boots outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet online
yeezy boost
adidas yeezy shoes
ugg shoes
ugg boots outlet
cheap ugg boots
air max shoes
ugg on sale
nike outlet store
pandora charms outlet
ugg outlet online
discount oakley sunglasses
polo ralph lauren
ralph lauren sale clearance uk
ralph lauren sale
adidas yeezy boost
mulberry uk
mlb jerseys whgolesale
cheap ray ban sunglasses
adidas store
retro 11
pandora uk
coach outlet store
coach outlet store online
jordans
pandora charms outlet
coach outlet online
cheap jordans
moncler outlet online
michael kors bags
canada goose outlet
kate spade outlet
uggs outlet
cheap nfl jerseys
coach outlet online
ralph lauren
uggs outlet
burberry outlet online
timberland outlet
ugg outlet
coach outlet store online
gucci outlet online
toms shoes
valentino outlet
tory burch outlet online
canada goose coats
coach purses
adidas outlet store
pandora jewelry
louis vuitton handbags
longchamp handbags
cheap ugg boots
polo ralph lauren outlet
nike outlet online
michael kors outlet store
christian louboutin shoes
hermes bags
michael kors outlet store
birkin handbags
coach factory outlet online
pandora uk
timberland outlet store
canada goose sale
michael kors outlet clearance
uggs outlet
ray ban sunglasses discount
longchamp bags
yeezy boost 350
louboutin outlet
ugg
harden shoes
discount ray ban sunglasses
cheap nike shoes
canada goose jacket
cheap air jordans
canada goose jackets
moncler sale
uggs outlet
discount oakley sunglasses
coach outlet store
ray ban sunglasses sale
adidas sneakers
michael kors outlet store
red bottoms
air jordan retro
nike huarache shoes
ray bans
hermes handbags
yeezy shoes
fred perry shirts
polo ralph lauren outlet online
ralph lauren sale
polo ralph lauren
adidas nmd r1
yeezy boost 350
hermens
christian louboutin sale
michael kors bags
ferragamo shoes
ray ban sunglasses discount
pandora charms sale clearance
cheap ugg boots
ugg boots
coach outlet online
mulberry
ugg boots
canada goose sale
pandora jewelry outlet
pandora charms
coach factory outlet online
birkenstock outlet
coach outlet online
kate spade outlet online
coach factory outlet online
adidas nmd r1
coach factory outlet
michael kors
ray ban glasses
adidas nmd runner
nike outlet
yeezy shoes
cheap jordan shoes
nike sneakers
adidas nmd runner
hermes bag
ugg outlet online
coach outlet online
beats headphones
beats wireless headphones
ferragamo outlet
uggs outlet
hermes outlet
ugg boots on sale
pandora charms outlet
cheap jordan shoes
canada goose
longchamp sale
ralph lauren outlet online
coach factory outlet online
moncler sale
ugg outlet
cheap ray ban sunglasses
oakley sunglasses outlet
longchamps
ray ban glasses
pandora charms sale clearance
ugg sale
canada goose sale
ugg boots
polo ralph lauren outlet
nfl jerseys
louis vuitton factory outlet
coach outlet store online clearance
adidas nmd r1
michael kors outlet online
toms
jordan shoes
moncler jackets
pandora charms sale
uggs outlet
coach factory outlet
canada goose sale
polo ralph lauren outlet online
the north face outlet
birkenstock shoes
coach outlet online
air max
michael kors handbags outlet
ugg boots outlet
michael kors outlet online
nmd adidas
pandora charms sale clearance
coach factory outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet
michael kors outlet online
air jordan shoes
09.17linpingping

By Anonymous (not verified)

Add new comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.
Real Time Analytics